
Five convicted criminals executed by hanging in Iran in 2007.
© AP/PA Photo/Halabisaz
Waiting to be put to death
All around the world men, women and sometimes even children, sit locked in jail cells awaiting their execution. Some of them have been tortured, and some have never even talked to a lawyer.
The death penalty is morally wrong and 10 October – World Day Against the Death Penalty – people all over the globe will be standing up and saying so.
They'll be rallying together to put pressure on the governments of the world to abolish the death penalty. So far 137 countries have banned executions, and just last year the United Nations passed a resolution calling for a global moratorium.
Asia executes hundreds
This year the focus is on Asia, which every year executes hundreds of people. In 2007 at least 664 executions were reported in Asia. The World Coalition Against the Death Penalty cite one study that estimates 85 per cent to 95 per cent of the world’s executions take place in Asia.
There is some good news in all this, because more Asian countries are also moving towards doing away with the death penalty. In Taiwan, Japan and South Korea, there is growing debate and pressure for abolition, and there's been unheard of discussion on the topic in Singapore and China.
Death penalty in Viet Nam
Viet Nam, however, is one of the 60 countries worldwide that persists in sentencing people to death.
The country's Ministry of Public Security in early 2006 proposed a reduction in the number of capital offences punishable by the death, recommending economic crimes should no longer be capital offences, but still it continues to hand out death sentences.
Our latest annual report says in Viet Nam in 2007 at least 83 people, including 14 women, were sentenced to death for drug trafficking offences, some after unfair trials. Though the true number of sentences given out is likely to be much higher
During that same year the country's Supreme People’s Court upheld at least 15 death sentences, including one imposed on a UK citizen of Vietnamese origin who reportedly suffered from mental health problems.
Facing firing squad
Among those Viet Nam has sentenced to death this year is Tang Thi Ba; a former post office treasurer convicted of embezzlement.
According to Thanh Nien News, one of Viet Nam's most circulated newspapers, she had embezzled more than 15 billion Vietnamese dong (about A$1.08 million). She admitted her crime to the court and was found guilty, says the paper, which is affiliated to the Ho Chi Minh Communist Youth Association.
It's likely Tang Thi Ba will be executed by a five-person firing squad, possibly in public. Her family will not be informed of her execution until after it is over.
We are writing to Viet Nam's President, His Excellency Nguyen Minh Triet, urging him to commute Thang Thi Ba's sentence and to do away with capital punishment altogether. You can join us.
Cruel and morally wrong
Amnesty International is against the use of the death penalty everywhere in the world, for whatever reason – it is never acceptable. Ever.
Whatever the men, women and children who are sentenced to death have done, whether they're guilty or innocent, not one of them deserves to be executed. The death penalty is cruel, inhuman and it’s morally wrong.
Take action for justice on 10 October.


Comments
James | Posted on 10 October 2008, 04:03PM | Report comment
If a person is proven innocent say 3 years after being found guilty and put in jail, they can be freed. If a person has been executed and they are then found to be innocent, they cannot be compensated and their family will still never see them again. See http://www.amnesty.org.au/china/comments/18107/ for a short video that presents exactly that incredibly tragic scenario.
It may seem to be a clear-cut argument that only the most horrendous crimes deserve execution, but who then decides what crimes are sufficiently offensive to justify the ultimate punishment? Is embezzelment of government funds a big enough crime to justify execution? Some countries believe so - see http://www.amnesty.org.au/centre/action/17859/. Unless you hold that execution is wrong in ALL cases, how can you really argue that they are wrong? Once we allow execution for some crimes, the range of crimes for which execution is a suitable penalty is open to interpretation.
Sabastian | Posted on 10 October 2008, 03:17PM | Report comment
I actually am pro death penalty, only for the most terrible of crimes. Everyone knows that the death penalty is extreme to put it lightly but is life behind bars much better? The fact of the matter is that there are some people who do terrible terrible things and that the only way to punish them and make society safe is to do something that most people would consider terrible in turn (life in jail, death penalty)
If the death penalty was removed what would be the sentence for the most horrendous crimes? Life in jail? Even thats terrible so lets get rid of that, then what?
Tanya | Posted on 10 October 2008, 01:54PM | Report comment
What is the reason for the death penalty? Is it to rid the world of the person who committed the crime or maybe to teach them a lesson? Whatever reason it is - its morally wrong not to mention ridiculously hypocritical!! Killing people for killing people….i beg to ask; who are the “REAL” criminals?
Takeia Beard | Posted on 7 October 2008, 08:08PM | Report comment
Why do people kill people who kill people to teach them that killing people is wrong? A tad hypocritical if you ask me…..
James Fehon | Posted on 6 October 2008, 10:11PM | Report comment
You can voice your opposition to the death penalty by coming along to Amnesty organised events in your area.
In NSW we’re laying the flags of all 60 countries still carrying out executions and gathering signatures in opposition from the public.
For details:
http://www.amnesty.org.au/nsw/event/18013/
For other states, check the Branch sites under “In your area” (in the top right of this page)
Guy Werner | Posted on 6 October 2008, 04:04PM | Report comment
The death penalty is barbaric and there is no recourse when someone is wrongly convicted. The probability of arrest, rather than the penalty, deters would-be criminals.
Keith | Posted on 4 October 2008, 09:09PM | Report comment
How are we ever able to
abolish the death penalty,
when we have the Australian
Prime Minister Kevin Rudd,
publicly commenting that the
Bali bombers deserve the
death penalty. It’s been
reported all over the
world media.
Habib | Posted on 4 October 2008, 06:44PM | Report comment
I am agree with some death penalty on crimes like killing to human beings. As, once a human want to kill a human, he should be faced as his planned.
In many crimes like not being killed to human but it just against the constitution or against the order, should not be used death penalty.
Anna Martin | Posted on 3 October 2008, 09:14PM | Report comment
On the eve of World Anti-Death Penalty Day, His Honour Justice Lex Lasry will be speaking in Melbourne: Thursday 9 October at the State Library, Melbourne. Justice Lasry is known for his advocacy on behalf of those facing the death penalty such as Nguyen Tuong.
This will be the inaugural Reprieve Australia lecture, please join us to mark World Anti-Death Penalty Day. Visit www.reprieve.org.au for more details.
Sandra Krof | Posted on 2 October 2008, 08:21PM | Report comment
When is the killing and retribution ever going to stop! Justice, does anyone even know the meaning of the word, or even care? As long as the ‘eye for an eye’ mentality prevails, this travesty,(the death penalty) done in the name of justice will continue.
Birte Lindell | Posted on 2 October 2008, 05:49PM | Report comment
Death Penalty is ultimativ and cannot resore a life taken. It is absolutely not acceptable.
C Jane Suttle | Posted on 2 October 2008, 02:39PM | Report comment
Killing another human being is NEVER ok. Killing a child is way worse than that.
louise van Embden | Posted on 2 October 2008, 12:54AM | Report comment
Please bring to an end the need to practice violence against violence abolish the death penalty now.
Maddie Stewart | Posted on 1 October 2008, 09:54PM | Report comment
The death penalty, especially when children are executed in this inhumane manner, is never acceptable. The Death Penalty has to be abolished.
Michele Ambrose | Posted on 1 October 2008, 09:43PM | Report comment
Think about the agonising mental cruelty of death row. Think about the accused waiting months and sometimes years in sterile, isolated environments for that final terrifying moment. Think about a new compassionate world without the death penalty
Gina Davidson | Posted on 1 October 2008, 09:04PM | Report comment
There is never an excuse to take a life no matter how horrific the crime because we become no better than the perpetrator. An eye for an eye has never solved a problem, rather it perpetuates violence.
Rebecca Hlodik | Posted on 1 October 2008, 08:43PM | Report comment
two wrongs don’t make a right.
Jean John | Posted on 1 October 2008, 06:46PM | Report comment
I am against the death penalty whatever the offence. We do not have the right to take another’s life.
Heather Hubert | Posted on 1 October 2008, 04:24PM | Report comment
On World Day Against the Death Penalty and every other day I vote against the death penalty in any shape or form for any reason whatever.
Peter Pearce | Posted on 1 October 2008, 04:24PM | Report comment
Life is too precious to be taken away/ Execution means we have failed to even try to rehabilitate and enlighten alleged offenders. Are we that poor in intellect, capability, re-education and compassion that we won’t attempt to give offenders a last chance?