Some Group 78 families chose to accept inadequate compensation and dismantle their own homes, with the assistance of a Government workforce © Nicolas Axelrod
Amnesty International condemns forced eviction of Cambodian families
The forced eviction of 60 low-income families in central Phnom Penh on Thursday and Friday has been strongly condemned by Amnesty International.
This is how the situation unfolded.
The families dismantled their homes after three years of government harassment and intimidation, with no choice but to accept inadequate compensation rather than have their homes demolished.
"Amnesty International strongly condemns this forced eviction and the deeply flawed process that led to it," said Brittis Edman, Amnesty International's Cambodia researcher.
Before dawn on Friday, at least 70 security forces, some armed with guns and electronic batons, moved in and blocked off the area known as Group 78 where four remaining families were holding out, with human rights workers and journalists monitoring the situation. Dozens of hired workers demolished what was left of the dismantled houses. Within hours, the resisting families had agreed to leave.
The families in Group 78 had been living under the threat of forced evictions for three years, with the Cambodian authorities following none of the safeguards required under international law.
"Group 78 was clearly cut off from due process and denied justice. The Municipality of Phnom Penh made no attempts to properly consult with the affected community or explore any feasible alternative to eviction," said Brittis Edman. "This makes a mockery of the government's obligations to protect the right to housing."
The Municipality issued a final eviction notice to Group 78 in April 2009 and, in a series of subsequent meetings, officials, including Phnom Penh's deputy governor, warned the community that the police and military police would demolish their homes if they did not accept the compensation on offer. The community had also received information that up to 700 security forces had been mobilised for the eviction.
Group 78 residents started moving into the area on the riverfront in 1983 and have applied for formal land titles several times since 2006, but the authorities have ignored their applications in spite of official documentation proving strong ownership claims. The final eviction order was issued by the Municipality, which has no mandate under national law to issue such a document, and without the judicial overview required under the 2001 Land Law. It was issued despite the fact that a local Commission has yet to determine who owns the disputed land. The options for alternative accommodation and compensation offered by the Municipality were inadequate.
The Cambodian Government has consistently failed to guarantee the right to adequate housing and protect its population against forced evictions. In 2008 alone, Amnesty International received reports about 27 forced evictions, affecting an estimated 23,000 people. Amnesty International is repeating its calls on the government to end forced evictions and introduce a moratorium on all mass evictions until the legal framework protects human rights.
As part of its Demand Dignity campaign, launched in May 2009, Amnesty International is calling on the Cambodian Government to end forced evictions and introduce a moratorium on all mass evictions until the legal framework protects human rights.
Through this campaign, the organisation is calling on governments globally to take all necessary measures, including the adoption of laws and policies that comply with international human rights law, to prohibit and prevent forced evictions.
We are monitoring the situation: Forced evictions in Cambodia: Group 78


Comments
Madeleine Kingston | Posted on 18 July 2009, 01:10PM | Report comment
I have just forwarded a personal email to the Australian Prime Minister seeking visible support in publicly condemning the Cambodian Government for its actions in forcibly evicting Cambodian families.
I have also sought a direct explanation from the PM as to what action the Australian Govt. may have taken in contributing to the pressure that should have been placed on the Cambodian Government regarding the unconscionable eviction of these families.
The PM has been urged to seek an explanation by the Cambodian Govt. for their actions since I believe that all Governments should take a united stance in condemning denial of fundamental human rights in the Group 78 evictions.
I urge others to similarly write directly to the PM seeking assurance that the Govt. will take a visible stance to support the immediate needs of the displaced families and to ensure that human rights and dignity are preserved by demanding the dignity that every person should expect.
Madeleine Kingston | Posted on 18 July 2009, 12:13PM | Report comment
I echo the question previously asked about what action the Australian government took - or failed to take to place pressure on the Cambodian Government prior to the unconscionable eviction of families. An explanation by the Cambodian Government should be proactively sought, and the matter repeatedly upheld as one of governmental failure and shame.
Louise Townend | Posted on 18 July 2009, 11:41AM | Report comment
Secure shelter is a basic human right. As a fellow human, please respect these people’s rights.
Madeleine Kingston | Posted on 18 July 2009, 11:35AM | Report comment
As observed by others commenting, when governments adopt a stance of either stripping away or otherwise eroding fundamental human needs, including physiological needs such shelter, clothing, food, other human needs also become compromised. Stripping people of their homes in the way that the Cambodian Government has achieved is a form of violence and bullying and should not be tolerated by the international community at any level. The campaigns to demand more dignity and fairness should be continued in such a way as to aim to shame this Government and others participating in such unacceptable conduct.
Shayne Elsley | Posted on 18 July 2009, 10:01AM | Report comment
Governments (and citizens) should not allow one of our most basic needs to be frittered away (or in this case eviction)
Madeleine Kingston | Posted on 18 July 2009, 01:53AM | Report comment
Amnesty International has advised that the Group 78 families had been living under the threat of forced evictions for three years.
The failure of the Cambodian Authorities to safeguard the fundamental rights of these families under international law represents, as observed by Brittis Edman “a mockery of the government’s obligations to protect the right to housing.”
It is the responsibility of the community as a whole and of all governments at global level to uphold the rights and dignity of individuals and communities.
The Cambodian Government must be condemned for its actions in forcibly and without just cause evicting Cambodian families.
Arturo Fatturi | Posted on 18 July 2009, 01:31AM | Report comment
I send a message to the Permanent Comission Ambassador in UN, Mr. Sea Kosal asking for toleerance and dignity in the treatment of Cambodjan people. A country who was almost devastated by Khmer Rouge cannot make the same errors against his people.
Madeleine Kingston | Posted on 18 July 2009, 12:28AM | Report comment
I am appalled to hear of the final outcomes in this matter despite the sterling efforts of organizations such as Amnesty International. The outcomes represent extreme violation of human rights. Forced evictions such as these are unacceptable to the community at large.
I am delighted to hear of Amnesty International will continue its efforts as part of the Demand Dignity campaign to call on the Cambodian Govt. to address the human rights issues involved. I applaud these goals.
What further action can I personally take to support the plight of Cambodian families who have been forcibly displaced from their homes?
Ann Garrick | Posted on 17 July 2009, 10:50PM | Report comment
Everybody has the right to shelter, a place to lay their roots, a place to establish their identity, a place to feel secure, a place to live free from threat, a place of their own to preserve their dignity. Please stop forced volient evictions
julian rey | Posted on 17 July 2009, 10:04PM | Report comment
why have they been evicted? what is it that is important to the authorities to make them disregard human rights and welfare? (and of their own people) if they want to shine a brighter light on the image of their city for an international eye, should we always remind them of the disgraceful shadow they’ve created?
Abdullah Alahmari | Posted on 17 July 2009, 09:45PM | Report comment
Everyone deserves a home. Why this peapole.
belinda philp | Posted on 17 July 2009, 09:42PM | Report comment
Please do not evict thee people.
christine berrill | Posted on 17 July 2009, 09:13PM | Report comment
What a terrible travesty, a disgrace and violation of Human rights…please give these people a better chance..by showing some compassion
Joseph O'Neill | Posted on 17 July 2009, 06:46PM | Report comment
This is appalling and a denial of human rights. How can we send an email etc?
Vicki Brooks | Posted on 17 July 2009, 06:40PM | Report comment
I believe that the human race has a long way still to go to be more kind and generous with each other. Remember whatever you do comes back to you somewhere in your life and life is like a ripple affect, if you are kind and compassionate this resonates out into your community, however, the opposite applies. Try to remember, this is very important to your country and the world.
Jenny Haines | Posted on 17 July 2009, 06:17PM | Report comment
Did the Australian Government make the representations we asked them to? If not, why not? If they did what was the Cambodian authorities explanation for this behaviour?
Ken Welsh | Posted on 17 July 2009, 05:54PM | Report comment
I am apalled at this outcome. Now that this terrible outcome has been perpetrated my grave concern is that these families are moved to a safe area with particular regard to the presence of undiscovered land mines. By their own reckoning there are over 2 million still dotted across the landscape.
Abdullah Alahmari | Posted on 17 July 2009, 05:54PM | Report comment
Getting a home is necessity of life. demilitarization of any family from her home is a frivolous and all religions reject any Frivolous conduct.
sara mitchel | Posted on 17 July 2009, 05:21PM | Report comment
I dont agree with the evictions at all, however, maybe one solution would be to assist in setting up micro financing for new work and business/infrastructure in the relocated regions of Cambodia.
Margaret Lee | Posted on 17 July 2009, 03:27PM | Report comment
I am disgusted at the sight of this article. You’d think that after the Khmer Rouge regime there would be more compassion towards people. I have been lucky enough to live in Italy & Australia thru migration, however I can only feel deeply for my poor people. What action is being taken or can be taken to prevent or legislate against this sort of action. This would be in no way whatsoever acceptable in Australia.