Print this Email this

Bali 9 decision - welcome news

6 March 2008, 11:36AM

Matthew Norman (L) and Tan Duc Thanh Nguyen (R)
Matthew Norman (L) and Tan Duc Thanh Nguyen (R), &copy AFP

Reports that three of the Bali 9 have had their death sentences reduced to life imprisonment is welcome news.

Matthew Norman, Si Yi Chen and Tan Duc Thanh have reportedly been spared execution after being convicted of smuggling drugs in Bali in 2005. We will continue to monitor the appeal process currently before Indonesia's Supreme Court, and look forward to an official announcement.

Three of the Bali 9 on death row – Scott Rush, Myuran Sukumaran and Andrew Chan – undertook an unsuccessful constitutional challenge in October 2007.

The Indonesian Constitutional Court ruled in a split decision not to support the legal challenge to repeal the provisions in the 1997 Narcotics Law. They remain on death row.

Renae Lawrence is serving a 20 year sentence and Michael Czugaj and Martin Stephens were sentenced to life imprisonment.

In total 11 people were sentenced to death in Indonesia last year.

We oppose the death penalty in all circumstances, as a violation to the right of life and the right not to be subjected to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.

While it is legitimate for the Indonesian government to take appropriate law-enforcement measures against drug offenders, there is no scientific evidence showing that the death penalty deters would-be traffickers more effectively than other punishments.

We call on the Indonesian government to follow the example set by 133 countries around the world which have already abolished the death penalty in law or practice, including neighbouring Philippines which abolished the death penalty in 2006.

The trend towards total abolition continued in 2007 with the the UN General Assembly adopting a resolution calling for a global moratorium on the death penalty. The resolution was supported by 99 countries in favour, with 52 countries against.

Features and analysis

Alyawarr women

Healthy homelands

An Aboriginal community in the Northern Territory is showing the government how to close the health gap.

A pregnant woman in Sierra Leone

Childbirth in Sierra Leone

Many women in Sierra Leone spend the final months of pregnancy and agonising hours of childbirth fearing for their lives.

cards of support created by Australian children

Harming Children

Professor Louise Newman explains how detaining children on Christmas Island is likely to affect their mental health.

These features are taken from our Human Rights Defender magazine - subscribe free now

Sorry, commenting is no longer available in this weblog entry.

Make an impact

You can make a difference right now. Your action will help to shine the light of hope into people's lives across the world.

You can make a difference right now. Your action will help shine the light of hope into people's lives across the world.

Check out what 110,738 people are doing right now to support human rights.

Act now

Stay Informed

Sign up for email updates

Subscribe using RSS

Get Involved

Two Columbian boys smiling and holding their arms out with their thumbs up - a sign of hope

Amnesty International relies on your support to continue our vital work protecting human rights. Please help us keep governments accountable, bring the guilty to justice, and save lives.

Donate